Keurig K55 vs K250

It’s time to compare one of Keurig’s cheaper coffee brewers with one of their expensive ones. We’re talking of course, about the Keurig K55 that’s priced at around $90 and the K250 which costs about a $100 more.

Other than the huge gap in their prices, these two Keurig brewers have quite a number of differences. This concerns their features, versatility, design, performance…etc.

People are also reading:

In this article, we will address these differences in detail. This way you can determine which of these two coffee makers is right for you.

Being the more expensive model, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that the K250 offers up more features than its rival. However, for those who just want a simple no-frills coffee maker, you can’t go wrong with the K55.

Keurig K55 vs K250 Coffee Maker Comparison

The Pros and Cons: Keurig K250 vs K55

In this section, we’re going to take a brief look at the advantages and disadvantages of buying each model from Keurig:

Keurig K55

The Keurig K55 is nothing fancy. It’s got buttons instead of a touchscreen. This makes the brewing experiences simple and streamlined. 

It comes fitted with a 48-ounce water reservoir, which should give you around six cups per refill. If you’re single or your family is small, you could make this last an entire day.

The K55 is only compatible with three brewing options, not including any K-carafe or K-mug sizes. Hence, if you like brewing coffee in larger batches then this could be a problem.

The K55 will brew a cup of coffee in under a minute, save on electricity with the Auto Off feature and take care of calcium deposits on its own with the included descaling option.  With all that for under $100, we consider the Keurig K55 to be a steal!

The Pros

  • It’s the more affordable option
  • The buttons make it a pretty straightforward operation
  • Auto On/Off feature
  • Descaling feature
  • Comes with a slightly larger water reservoir (48 ounces)
  • Removable drip tray

The Cons

  • It can get quite noisy
  • No touchscreen
  • It takes up a lot of space
  • No temperature or strength controls
  • Only compatible with 3 brewing quantities.

Keurig K250 Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker

The Keurig K250 is slimmer than the K55. Furthermore:

  • It comes with a 2-inch black and white touch screen, which is a nice, modern addition
  • It’s compatible with 4 K-cup and 3 K-carafe sizes. This makes the K55 better suited to serve larger households
  • It can dispense hot water so you don’t have to bother with a kettle
  • It comes with strength control, so that you’re able to switch from mild to strong coffee in an instant.

The biggest downsides are that the K250 is more expensive and its water reservoir is small compared to that of the K55.

The Pros

  • Comes with a touchscreen
  • Can dispense hot water
  • Auto Off feature
  • Descaling option
  • Compatible with more brew sizes
  • Slimmer than the K55
  • Removable drip tray

The Cons

  • It’s the more expensive option
  • Has a smaller water tank that the K55
  • No temperature controls
  • Doesn’t come with an Auto-On feature

Comparison: Keurig K55 vs K250

In this section, we’re going to be taking a closer look at the differences and similarities between the Keurig K55 and K250.

Design

Both the K55 and K250 would certainly look great in any kitchen. However, the K250 sports more of a modern look, largely thanks to the presence of a touchscreen. It’s also slimmer and less heavy than the K55.

The K55 measures 9.8 x 13.3 x 13 inches and weighs 10 pounds. In contrast, the K250 measures 15 x 9 x 13.7 inches and weighs 7.5 pounds.

The Keurig K250 single serve k-cup pod coffee maker is available in more colours than the K55. The exact options are as follows:

  • K55: Black, red, coconut white and patriot blue
  • K50: Black and red

Features

If you choose to buy the Keurig K55 the biggest size you’ll be brewing is 10 ounces. In contrast, the K250 is compatible with K-carafe pods. This means you’ll be able to brew up to 30 ounces, which is four cups at once! So the K250 can be quite handy if you’ve got a lot of coffee drinkers in your house. That being said, the K55 does come with the larger water reservoir, which means you’ll have to refill less often.

One of the biggest differences between the two brewers is that the K250 comes fitted with a touchscreen while the latter doesn’t. However, this shouldn’t really be a problem if you’re just looking for a simple coffee machine.

Something else that the K250 has (that its rival lacks) is a strength control, which allows you to brew mild, strong or even extra strong coffee with no extra effort required.

The Auto Off feature on both coffee makers helps you save a ton of energy. What it does is turn off the coffee brewer after about 90 seconds of inactivity.

Versatility

Both Keurig brewers are versatile in different ways. The K250 allows you to brew in seven different sizes (including carafe quantities) but it’s only compatible with Keurig brand pods.

On the other hand, you can only brew in 3 different quantities with the K55 but it’s compatible with non-Keurig pods as well.

Ease of Use

There’s really nothing to complain about the ease of use of either coffee maker. The controls are pretty straightforward and you’ll have your coffee in less than a minute with a few button presses.

Both brewing systems are easy to clean as well. This is largely thanks to the fact that their drip trays and water tanks are removable. Plus the descaling option helps eliminate any pesky mineral deposits.

As with all Keurig machines, you have to swap out the water filter every two months or so. Luckily, this process is easy and takes hardly any time. We recommend that you always buy a charcoal water filter every time. They’re so much better at getting rid of impurities.

Conveniently, you can buy a water filter kit for both brewers from Amazon for cheap.

You can always contact Keurig’s excellent customer service if there are any problems. They handle returns and repairs quite professionally. Just ask anyone who’s dealt with them! However, it would have been nicer to get a longer warranty period for these machines.

Price

Price is where the Keurig 55 has a very clear edge over its rival. It costs about $90 to buy a brand new K55 while a Keurig K250 single serve K-cup pod coffee maker K250 is priced $298.

What Do Customers Have To Say?

We combed through the customer reviews on Amazon and here’s a sum up of what customers are saying about each coffee machine:

Keurig K55

As per many reviews, customers appear to love the simplicity of the K55. All you need to do is select your preferences and place a pod, and you’ve got a lovely cup of coffee in under a minute. In addition, users love the fact that you can use pods from different brands, which can often be a money-saver.

There are two main complaints about the K55. The first is that it can get quite noisy. Secondly, some customers state that their units started to malfunction after only a few months of use.

Keurig K250

There are a lot of things that customers appear to love about this product. This includes the presence of a touch display, and the variety of colour options and K-pod sizes. The thing that they don’t like is the fact that you can’t use non-Keurig pods with K250. There seem to be quite a few mentions of this in the reviews.

Our Verdict: Keurig K55 vs K250

Both the Keurig K55 and K250 are great coffee brewers and either one is guaranteed to delight the average coffee drinker. That being said, we have to bestow the winner’s title on the K250. We have three reasons for doing so:

First of all, it’s got a slimmer design and comes in a greater variety of colour options. Secondly, it comes with strength control so that you can have milder or stronger brews at the press of a button. Last but not least, you can brew in seven different sizes (including carafe sizes), which can really come in handy when you’re having friends and family over.

Keurig K250 Coffee Maker
Keurig K250

In Conclusion: Which Product Is Better For Your Kitchen?

Even though the K250 is our pick, we’d actually recommend the K55 over it to a few different types of people.

For instance, if you’re on a tight budget and don’t really care for things like a touch screen or diverse colour options, then you’d be quite happy with K55. Also by using non-Keurig pods, you might be able to save money down the line as well.

Plus, if you hate refilling the water reservoir and want to do it as fewer times as possible, then again, the K55 is the brewer for you.

On the other hand, if you don’t mind spending an extra $100 for a touch screen, strength controls and more brew sizes, then, by all means, go for the K250.